I have had two different statisticians give me totally opposite answers to the question of
the validity of tests for certain data sets and on more than one occasion been told that either my data collection or analysis methods will depend on what I want to find out.
Not exact matches
All the theists, who work
for Walmart but like to post on the Inter-webs, will now call into question the
validity of radio carbon
testing.
Such arguments as «the Church teaches --» were destined to become less and less sufficient to win immediate acceptance
for the ideas they prefaced The
validity of traditions was questioned; general beliefs about physical phenomena were subjected to various
tests.
You might not be aware, but the educational system teaches kids to think
for themselves, ask questions, scrutinize the
validity of an explanation or an authority figure, and use inductive and deductive reasoning as a part
of a process to ask questions, analyze and
test a hypothesis.
Regardless
of the origin
of an idea, the idea can be
tested for validity.
This would not only open up the possibility
of fraudulent imitations, it would also cause chaos
for the payment industry, who look
for small, token payments as a sign that criminals are «
testing» the
validity of stolen card details.
the epistemology
of physics: Epistemology is the study
of the nature, source, limits, and
validity of knowledge, and
for physics that means how physics devises and
tests its theories concerning physical phenomena;
Researchers also
tested the
validity of conscious experiences using objective markers
for the first time in a large study to determine whether claims
of awareness compatible with out -
of - body experiences correspond with real or hallucinatory events.
«It's important
for us to study materials from asteroids and meteorites, the smaller versions
of asteroids that fall to Earth, to
test the
validity of our models
for how molecules in them could have helped give rise to life.
They are regulated by the Centers
for Medicare & Medicaid Services through the 1988 Clinical Laboratory Improvement Amendments (CLIA), but FDA has argued that this oversight only makes sure
tests are performed properly, and doesn't review the underlying
validity of the answers the
tests give.
To understand the evidence
for the evaluation
of genetic
testing and how it differs from other evidence - based decisions, Dr. Lyon describes the «ACCE» framework
for evaluating analytic and clinical
validity and utility.
In civil cases, such as a lawsuit
for damages from a vehicle accident or from a medical problem,
testing and analysis by a qualified forensic scientist may be used by either side to address the
validity of the allegations in the suit.
LA JOLLA — With forensic science facing mounting scrutiny as it plays an increasingly prominent role in the administration
of justice, six scientists who recently served on the National Commission on Forensic Science are calling on the scientific community at large to advocate
for increased research and financial support
of forensic science as well as the introduction
of empirical
testing requirements to ensure the
validity of outcomes.
While more research needs to be done on the
validity, sensitivity, and specificity
of the
testing for SIBO, there is data that shows the relationship between SIBO and IC.
This is the first effort to systematically identify opportunities
for score inflation, to explore variations in
validity across parts
of tests and across types
of students and schools, and to implement and evaluate SMAs.
Three months after the debut
of the SAT writing
test, some colleges are expressing concerns about its
validity, and many have decided not to require the scores, at least
for the time being.
By examining rigorous evidence about the
validity of both
of these
tests, however, Massachusetts provides a model
for other states facing difficult choices about whether and how to upgrade their assessment systems.
At the root
of Martiniello's research is a quest
for fairness and equity by questioning the
validity of standardized math
tests, given their significant implications on students» lives.
Choosing this
test as a basis
for considering the impact
of high - stakes
tests on students in the 4th and 8th grades (ages 9 and 13, respectively) is a sensible idea, because the
validity and reliability
of NAEP, often called the «nation's report card,» are well accepted.
We have identified specific questions that we will continue to discuss with the STA, to help them to enhance the
validity of the reading and maths
tests, over time,
for all pupils.»
But that affects the
validity of my analysis only if the NAEP
test accommodation policy
for New York City changed over the course
of the time period we are discussing.
In their analysis, NORC researchers Nick Rabkin and Eric Hedberg
test and ultimately confirm the
validity of an assumption made with prior SPPA data, that participation in arts lessons and classes is the most significant predictor
of arts participation later in life, even after controlling
for other variables.
The key to this failure was cheap, primitive teacher - evaluation systems that failed fundamental
tests of reliability and
validity and, therefore, could not allow
for differential rewards
for teachers.
Research efforts are aimed,
for example, at ensuring bias - free results,
validity of technology - enhanced items, stability
of measuring student growth across time, developing
testing accommodations
for students with special needs, software
for computer - based
testing, and technical support and scoring
for local standards - based assessments in Iowa and the nation.
Promote the assessment
of critical thinking as a necessary student outcome
for success; ensure assessments used show discriminant
validity from standard achievement or intellectual
tests
Doug Edelstein, a history teacher at Nathan Hale who questions the
validity of the
tests, said juniors and their parents decided
for themselves the
tests were a waste
of time.
This path analytic technique allows
for testing the
validity of causal inferences
for pairs
of variables while controlling
for the effects
of other variables.
In a similar vein, W. James Popham, professor emeritus at UCLA and
test design expert, has concluded that the use
of students»
test scores to evaluate teachers «runs counter to the most important commandment
of educational
testing — the need
for sufficient
validity evidence.»
These findings led the researchers to call
for further research on issues related to the specificity
of the frameworks, effects on equity, inflated
test scores, and the
validity of the measures.
«All
of us think our children should be challenged by difficult tasks in school and that the performance
of teachers in the classroom should be judged by the highest standards, but there is no scientific
validity whatsoever to the use
of high stakes
tests as the primary instrument
for evaluating children and teachers.
Technical Report # 9: Silent Reading Fluency
Test: Reliability,
Validity, and Sensitivity to Growth
for Students Who Are Deaf and Hard
of Hearing at the Elementary, Middle School, and High School Levels
Summary: Students who took the 2014 - 15 PARCC exams via computer tended to score lower than those who took the exams with paper and pencil — a revelation that prompts questions about the
validity of the
test results and poses potentially big problems
for state and district leaders.
Popham writes that the
validity of a
test, such as SBAC, which is designed to evaluate school and district performance, is rendered invalid if it is used
for purposes not fully supported by evidence.
The study
of 600 teachers, conducted by Abacus Associates
for the Connecticut Education Association, underscores mounting concerns by legislators, educators, parents, and others about the
test's
validity, fairness, and negative impact on students — particularly those in high - poverty districts and those with limited access to computers.
Indeed, the fact that Standards
for Educational and Psychological
Testing (AERA, APA, & NCME, 2014) opens with the first three chapters focused on the foundations
of validity, reliability and fairness underscores the importance
of consideration
of these elements in all assessment.
In response to concerns about
test validity, state leaders have agreed to a full review
of the assessments before the results are used
for teacher evaluations or school grades.
Tools and processes that pass the
tests of reliability and
validity, and that are flexible enough to take different school contexts into account (leading a large suburban high school,
for example, is different from leading a small rural elementary school).
Evidence
of whether the achievement
tests in use can actually detect the influence
of instruction on student
test performance should, accordingly, be a central part
of validity evidence required
for VAMs [as per the specific standard also mentioned above].
Specifically, her research includes the effect
of the ELL classification on students» long - term academic performance and educational experiences and aims to examine the
validity and reliability
of standardized
tests for ELLs.
One widely publicized study, which created a statistical
test of the
validity of value - added measures, [10] found reason
for concern.
During her 13 years at Pearson, she was responsible
for the planning, management and coordination
of the full array
of psychometric activities necessary to sustain a large scale assessment program, including
test design and development, scaling and equating, item and
test analysis, parameter estimation, standard setting, the development
of reliability and
validity research, report design, and the creation
of technical documentation.
There is no indication that NMPED has evaluated the reliability or
validity of these three very different observation methods, or
tested their results
for equivalence.
This new law will provide a measure
of protection
for our teachers, districts and students from consequences
for student
test scores on a standardized
test whose
validity and reliability as a tool
for measuring their performance is not supported by data.
He's instructed his staff to prepare materials
for families telling them not to put much credence into the Florida Standards Assessments scores and school grades this year, particularly in light
of a recent
validity study that raised many questions about the
test's reliability.
- the end
of MCAS as a graduation requirement; - the redesign and streamlining
of the existing
test; - the use
of MCAS
for diagnostic purposes only; - review
of MCAS and the Massachusetts Curriculum Frameworks by professional education associations; - an independent review
of MCAS
for validity and reliability; and - a comprehensive assessment system
for schools.
Navigio — The
validity problem due to lack
of appropriate implementation stems primarily from the «opportunity to learn» requirement
for large scale high stakes
tests that was advanced in the late 70's
for the first statewide high school graduation
tests, with that requirement established by the courts in 1978 and having held up
for more than 35 years
for the design and implementation
of all large scale K - 12
tests.
The purpose
of the current study was to analyze the relationship between automated essay scoring (AES) and human scoring in order to determine the
validity and usefulness
of AES
for large - scale placement
tests.
Questions posed after reading the prompt inspired students to investigate the history
of the exam resulting in learning about the history
of reform in Massachusetts and to interview principals and parents
for other points
of view,
test validity and reliability, as well as student points
of view.
This raises doubts
for educators about the
validity of this year's assessment, given the number
of changes made to
testing for this school year.
Gary: with all due respect
for those who post here, thank you
for your patience with nit - picking, e.g., we could argue interminably over the use
of the terms «
validity» and «reliability» and «bias» as they are used generally and as they are used in very specific ways by psychometricians when talking about the construction and administration
of standardized
tests and the inferences that could be drawn about
test scores.