In this edition I talk with Chris Suellentrop,
video game critic for the New York Times, and Steve Gaynor of the Fullbright Company, an indie game studio developing Gone Home, a finalist for the Excellence in Narrative award at the Indpendent Games Festival later this month.
Lara Croft soon gained praise among
video game critics for being a tough, resourceful female protagonist in a male - dominated medium, achieving icon status alongside the likes of Mario and Link.
Not exact matches
An article on Thursday about threats against
critics of the
video game industry misstated, at one point, part of the name of a lobbying group
for video game companies.
It may be
game over
for critics who claim that
video games are nothing more than a fun diversion.
Another plus
for many
critics is the fact that the GamePad can be used to play (some, but not all)
games and watch
video even when your TV is off (as long as you are within range of the Wii U console, that is, though Eurogamer notes that, «unless you're gaming in Wayne Manor,» range shouldn't be an issue).
The words «based on a
video game» have yielded mostly negative connotations among
critics and viewers looking
for fare with depth.
PURE won numerous awards, including the
Game Critics Award: Best of E3 2008
for Best Racing
Game, and was named among the top ten
video games of 2008 by Entertainment Weekly.
Kyd also created the faded Americana acoustic score
for Undead Labs» STATE OF DECAY, the fastest selling original
game on Xbox Live Arcade, and the surreal fantasy score for the action - adventure DARKSIDERS II, created by comic book writer / artist Joe Madureira, which garnered numerous critic accolades including Entertainment Weekly's «Most Played Best Songs of 2012,» Machinima's «Top 5 Songs of 2012,» «Best Video Game Score of 2012» and «Top 10 Best Video Game Scores Ever» from Minnesota Public Ra
game on Xbox Live Arcade, and the surreal fantasy score
for the action - adventure DARKSIDERS II, created by comic book writer / artist Joe Madureira, which garnered numerous
critic accolades including Entertainment Weekly's «Most Played Best Songs of 2012,» Machinima's «Top 5 Songs of 2012,» «Best
Video Game Score of 2012» and «Top 10 Best Video Game Scores Ever» from Minnesota Public Ra
Game Score of 2012» and «Top 10 Best
Video Game Scores Ever» from Minnesota Public Ra
Game Scores Ever» from Minnesota Public Radio.
Tetris was far and away the consensus choice
for «The Scientifically Proven Best
Video Game of All Time,» with strong support from critics and other game writers over two deca
Game of All Time,» with strong support from
critics and other
game writers over two deca
game writers over two decades.
The broader context
for it is a
video by John Bain (nee Total Biscuit) that's ostensibly appealing
for critics to be more objective in their approach to
video game reviews.
«To put it simply, a METASCORE is a weighted average of reviews from top
critics and publications
for a given movie, TV show,
video game, or album.»
Show friend Brad Gallaway from
Game Critics & the So...
Video Games Podcast fills in
for Todd this week.
While I do usually wait
for a
game to release to support it (as you surmised), I do not trust the majority of
critic scores due to the various developments in
video game journalism in recent years.
Why Spielberg was deemed the ideal
critic for assessing the progress of
video games is a mystery, since he infamously gave his approval to the E.T.
video game produced
for the Atari 2600 in the early 80s, which is now widely regarded as one of the worst
games ever made.
For the last several years, we've heard from many
critics that
video games need to grow up.
The Nintendo Switch was the second highest - selling
video game console in 2017, and one of its flagship
games,, was far and away the
critics» top pick
for the best
game of 2017.
(«Then were created the gods in the midst of heaven», ABZU); winner —
Game Audio Network Guild Awards, «Best Audio
for an Indie
Game» (The Banner Saga 2); nominated — International Film Music
Critics Association, «Best Original Score
for a
Video Game» (ABZU); winner — International Film Music
Critics Association, «Best Original Score
for a
Video Game» (The Banner Saga 2); nominated — BSO GoldSpirit Awards, «Best Score
for a
Video Game» (ABZU); nominated — Movie Music UK 2016, «Best
Video Game Score» (ABZU); nominated — MundoBSO.com, «Best Videogame Soundtrack» (ABZU); nominated — Hollywood Music in Media Awards, «Best Score — Videogame» (Deformers); nominated
-- Grammy Awards, «Best Score Soundtrack Album» (Journey); nominated — Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences, DICE Award «Outstanding Achievement in Music Composition» (Journey) winner — British Academy Awards, «Games / Original Music» (Journey); winner — British Academy Awards, «Games / Outstanding Achievement in Audio» (Journey); winner —
Game Audio Network Guild Awards, «Music of the Year» (Journey); winner —
Game Audio Network Guild Awards, «Audio of the Year» (Journey); nominated —
Game Audio Network Guild Awards, «Best Interactive Score» (Journey); winner —
Game Audio Network Guild Awards, «Best Original Instrumental» («Apotheosis», Journey); winner —
Game Audio Network Guild Awards, «Best Original Vocal (Pop)» («I Was Born
For This», Journey); winner — Game Audio Network Guild Awards, «Best Soundtrack album» (Journey); winner — Game Developer Choice Awards, «Audio of the Year» (Journey); winner — International Music and Sound Awards, «Best Original Composition — Gaming» (Journey); winner — Music and Sound Awards UK, «Best Original Composition — Gaming» (Journey); winner — Original Sound Version, «Composer of the Year [2012]» (Journey); winner — Original Sound Version, «Best In - Game Soundtrack [2012]» (Journey); winner — International Film Music Critics Association, «Best Original Score for a Video Game» (Journey); winner — New York Videogame Critics Circle Awards, «Tin Pan Alley Award for Best Music» (Journey); winner — Hollywood Music in Media Awards, «Best Song — Videogame» (BeatBuddy: Stingin» Swing); nomina
For This», Journey); winner —
Game Audio Network Guild Awards, «Best Soundtrack album» (Journey); winner —
Game Developer Choice Awards, «Audio of the Year» (Journey); winner — International Music and Sound Awards, «Best Original Composition — Gaming» (Journey); winner — Music and Sound Awards UK, «Best Original Composition — Gaming» (Journey); winner — Original Sound Version, «Composer of the Year [2012]» (Journey); winner — Original Sound Version, «Best In -
Game Soundtrack [2012]» (Journey); winner — International Film Music
Critics Association, «Best Original Score
for a Video Game» (Journey); winner — New York Videogame Critics Circle Awards, «Tin Pan Alley Award for Best Music» (Journey); winner — Hollywood Music in Media Awards, «Best Song — Videogame» (BeatBuddy: Stingin» Swing); nomina
for a
Video Game» (Journey); winner — New York Videogame
Critics Circle Awards, «Tin Pan Alley Award
for Best Music» (Journey); winner — Hollywood Music in Media Awards, «Best Song — Videogame» (BeatBuddy: Stingin» Swing); nomina
for Best Music» (Journey); winner — Hollywood Music in Media Awards, «Best Song — Videogame» (BeatBuddy: Stingin» Swing); nominated
(«The Knights» Theme», The Order 1886 [shared w / Jason Graves]-RRB-; nominated — Hollywood Music in Media Awards, «Best Score — Videogame» (ABZU); nominated — Movie Music UK 2015, «Best
Video Game Score» (Assassin's Creed: Syndicate); winner — Movie Music UK 2015, «Best Original Song» («Underground,» Assassin's Creed: Syndicate [shared w / Tripod]-RRB-; winner — International Film Music
Critics Association, «Best Original Score
for a
Video Game» (Assassin's Creed: Syndicate); winner — Annual
Game Music Awards, «Best Score, Cinematic / orchestral» (Assassin's Creed: Syndicate); nominated — Annual
Game Music Awards, «Artist of the Year: Western Composer» (Assassin's Creed: Syndicate, Sunset); nominated — MundoBSO.com, «Best Videogame Soundtrack» (Assassin's Creed: Syndicate); winner — IGN.com, Best of 2015, «Best Original Music» (Assassin's Creed: Syndicate); nominated
(«Underground», Assassin's Creed: Syndicate [shared w / Tripod]-RRB-; nominated —
Game Audio Network Guild Awards, «Best Audio
for an Indie
Game» (The Banner Saga); winner —
Game Audio Network Guild Awards, «Best Soundtrack Album» (The Banner Saga); nominated —
Game Audio Network Guild Awards, «Best Original Instrumental» («Of Our Bones, The Hills», The Banner Saga); nominated — BSO GoldSpirit Awards, «Best Score
for a
Video Game» (The Banner Saga); nominated — International Film Music
Critics Association, «Best Original Score
for a
Video Game» (The Banner Saga); nominated — SXSW Gaming Awards, «Excellence in Musical Score» (The Banner Saga); nominated — NAVGTR
Game Awards, «Original Dramatic Score, New IP» (The Banner Saga); nominated — Annual
Game Music Awards, «Best Score, Cinematic / orchestral» (The Banner Saga); nominated — Annual
Game Music Awards, «Artist of the Year: Outstanding Contribution, Western Composer» (The Banner Saga, Soul Fjord); nominated — Annual
Game Music Awards, «Outstanding Achievement: Music Production» (The Banner Saga); winner
Resistance: Burning Skies has been nominated
for an International Film Music
Critic Association award in the «Best Original Score
for a
Video Game or Interactive Media.»
Considered by
critics and fans alike to be a pinnacle of the
video games medium, The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim is also revered
for its triumphant musical score.
Outcast has been hailed by
critics and received numerous awards
for the quality of its graphics and innovative gameplay, and is a milestone in the history of
video games.
When it first launched, The Legend of Zelda: Wind Waker wasn't taken seriously
for its art direction, but it grew on
critics so much over time that some say it's one of the greatest
video games ever made because of characters» expressions, finely detailed environments, responsive controls, fluid combat action and puzzles.
In addition to introducing the main character with a story rich background, Grand Theft Auto 3 was also the first
game in the series built using a 3D
game engine and it quickly became the best - selling
video game for 2001 and was praised by fans and
critics alike despite some backlash surrounding the
game's violent gameplay and story.
And by sore point, I mean a lot of people want their politics and their
games kept separate in any publicized discussion on the topic, calling
for critics, journalists and developers to keep their filthy political agendas out of
video games in a spirited pursuit
for objective criticism.
Polygon's 2017 Year in Review:
video game essays from designers, authors and
critics (Chris Suellentrop / Polygon — ARTICLE) «
For a week, Polygon asked me to bring my fantasy universe to the real one.
The Times» videogame
critic, Seth Schiesel, finds that at a time when smartphones can be used to play
video games, Sony's new PlayStation Vita makes the case
for a separate mobile device.
Metacritic —
for those who don't know — compiles review scores from major
video game critics to find the average score.
This is the same
for video game critics.
Independent
Video Game Critic Jim Sterling investigated the surge of advertorials involving gambling websites and apps and found that the companies who pay
for websites to write advertorials not only didn't require disclosure but encouraged clients to mask the fact that the article is an advertorial.
Kane & Lynch 2: Dog Days is a
video game destined to become notorious not only
for its copious amounts of bloody violence and mature subject matter, but
for the way it has divided
critics upon release.
With the powerful reaction from God of War Director seeing the massively positive reviews of the title to the recent influencer controversy of Rockfish Games» Everspace and the ability
for anyone to be a
critic on Metacritic, Steam and social media, the legitimacy of
game reviews in today's
video game industry has been brought into the spotlight.
Visually Trap Team looks great and other
video game critics have commented that it's a significant leap over last year's Swap Force, especially the next - gen versions of the
game (I played the Xbox One version
for this review).
None of the three conservative
critics in attendance have any particular focus on
video games, and each is better known
for their work in other areas.