The most careful, comprehensive study of virtual charter schools, from Stanford's Center for Research on Education Outcomes, found that
virtual charter students achieved the equivalent of 180 fewer days of learning in math and 72 fewer days of learning in reading than students in traditional public schools.
Because
virtual charter students are pulled from districts across the state, Schauss said the funding formula is slightly different from traditional public schools, which rely on enrollment projections to help guide appropriations.
The study, completed by Stanford's Center for Research on Education Outcomes, found that, in a 180 - day academic year,
virtual charter students lagged behind their peers by an average of 72 days in reading, and 180 days in math.
Poston pointed out that these school systems will have to take in the fleeing
virtual charter students, with or without the lost cash.
A much - cited Stanford University study last fall found that
some virtual charter students can trail their traditional school peers by up to an entire academic year.
Poston is referring to a 2015 Stanford University study that found
virtual charter students may trail their peers in traditional public schools by as much as an entire academic year.
Not exact matches
Despite the united front of opposition, with studies like Carol Klein's 2006
Virtual Charter Schools and Home Schooling finding high levels of parent satisfaction and student achievement at virtual schools, it is highly unlikely that independent home schoolers and advocates for traditional public schools will be able to sto
Virtual Charter Schools and Home Schooling finding high levels of parent satisfaction and
student achievement at
virtual schools, it is highly unlikely that independent home schoolers and advocates for traditional public schools will be able to sto
virtual schools, it is highly unlikely that independent home schoolers and advocates for traditional public schools will be able to stop them.
Virtual charter schools can attract
students from all around the state, without regard to any traditional school - district boundary.
But in too many parts of the country, weak authorizing systems have encouraged a proliferation of
charter schools — particularly
virtual and for - profit ones — that don't serve
students well and taint the broader reputation of
charters.
Research that painstakingly tries to separate out the actual effects of schools clearly has value, but it is important to bear in mind that, in the absence of random assignment of
students to schools (such as occurs via
charter school lotteries), families that choose for their children to be educated in their home (through
virtual schools) are likely to be very different from other families.
Worrying about its impact to the point of delaying the opening of
virtual charter schools, which provide an option that is critical for some
students» success, does not make sense.
States are right to be concerned about how to best regulate
virtual charter schools — they ought to measure their results based on the growth of individual
students and shut down poorly performing ones.
In my own address to the Society for Information Technology and Teacher Education this year, I reported that K - 12 online education options continue to expand, with
students participating in site - based online labs, hybrid courses, and part - and full - time
virtual options that are offered by a variety of providers including
charter schools, districts, state supplemental programs, corporations, and colleges.
That group (full disclosure — I am a member) has proposed giving incentives to states if they enact legislation that encourage community colleges, universities,
charter schools, and other providers to offer
virtual courses to high school and middle school
students over the internet.
Online (or
virtual)
charter schools are typically nonprofit organizations authorized to serve
students anywhere in a given state.
And fourth, it appears to be taking my colleague Heather Staker's advice to heart by working closely with its
charter school boards and district partnerships to better align its outreach and enrollment to the
students who are best suited for success in full - time
virtual schools.
The roadblocks are especially severe when
virtual schools also tie in with other controversial reforms, such as
charter schools, contracting out to private management companies, and the interdistrict competition for
students generated by open enrollment.
Without test results, for instance, we would not know that online and
virtual charters appear to be demonstrably harmful to
students, as are many Louisiana private schools attended by
students using vouchers.
Put aside that it's likely that both the authors of the study and the schools themselves have points in their favor — the full - time
virtual charter schools themselves have in the past been transparent about some of their academic struggles, and, at the same time, in their criticism of the study, those same schools are surely right that the characteristics and motivation of some of their
students for attending full - time
virtual charters makes them quite unlike the «
virtual twins» the study purports to have found for the purposes of comparison.
Put aside the crystal clear anecdotes that go beyond the on average results — something education researchers are not good at doing — that show that for certain
students in certain circumstances, full - time
virtual charter schools are absolutely the best place for them to learn and that these
students have not only been successful in these environments, they have also thrived in ways they would not have in traditional brick - and - mortar schools.
CREDO controlled for the unique characteristics of
students enrolled in
virtual charter schools by comparing their performance to a «
virtual twin,» a
student with the same demographic characteristics and similar prior achievement enrolled in a traditional public school.
Put aside the fact that full - time
virtual charter schools are not for everyone and may now be serving
students who are not good fits for what they offer.
Evergreen Education Group, a leading consultancy in the digital learning field, estimates that 275,000
students are enrolled full - time in
virtual charter schools.
To provide
students with better options in the future, authorizers need to close
virtual charter schools that are persistently failing.
iNACOL has five criteria that it recommends policymakers judge full - time
virtual charter schools by: individual
student growth, proficiency, graduation rates, college and career readiness, and closing the achievement gap.
Unlike
charter schools, which must be open to all, enrollment criteria should be established for
virtual schools based on factors proven necessary for
student success.
Mechanisms we espouse, such as
student - based funding, open enrollment systems,
charter schools, and
virtual education, are having some success in breaking open the current system, but they require very special circumstances at the state and local level.
While the vast majority of FLVS
students come from district schools (82 percent in 2007 - 08), the school is open to
charter, private, and home - schooled
students (see «
Virtual Schools,» forum, Winter 2009).
Lawmakers could explore rules that exempt e-schools from policies requiring all
charters,
virtual ones included, to accept every
student who applies and instead allow e-schools to operate more like magnet schools with admissions procedures and priorities.
Many state programs, for instance in Florida where Julie heads up the Florida
Virtual School, allow all
students — public / private /
charter / home school to take courses.
The research team contributed, for example, to the reporting projects Black
Students More Likely to Be Arrested at School, A
Virtual Mess: Inside Colorado's Largest Online
Charter School, and Corporal Punishment Use Found in Schools in 21 States.
Several states — including Florida, New Mexico, and Utah — have passed recent legislation requiring that districts allow
students to choose their own online learning providers, whether that means state - run online schools,
virtual charters, or private providers.
School: VLACS Aspire Grades Served: 5 - 12 Location: New Hampshire Operator:
Virtual Learning Academy
Charter School Operator Type:
Charter Students at Opening: 1,391
Students at Capacity: 2,058
He cites a national study, CREDO, which found
students in Newark
charters gaining the equivalent of seven months in reading and nine in math, compared to
virtual counterparts.
This report, by Lauren Morando Rhim and Julie Kowal, describes how educating
students with disabilities in
virtual charter schools entails not only molding state
charter school laws to fit a specialized type of
charter school, but also adapting federal and state special education guidelines aimed at providing special education in traditional brick and mortar settings.
During his eight years in Tallahassee, the governor established a far - reaching accountability system, including limits on social promotion in elementary school; introduced a plethora of school choice initiatives (vouchers for the disabled, vouchers for those in failing schools, tax - credit funded scholarships for the needy,
virtual education, and a growing number of
charter schools); asked school districts to pay teachers according to merit; promoted a «Just Read» initiative; ensured parental choice among providers of preschool services; and created a highly regarded system for tracking
student achievement.
To argue that she has been even moderately successful with her approach, we would have to ignore the legitimate concerns of local and national
charter reformers who know the city well, and ignore the possibility that Detroit
charters are taking advantage of loose oversight by cherry - picking
students, and ignore the very low test score growth in Detroit compared with other cities on the urban NAEP, and ignore the policy alternatives that seem to work better (for example, closing low - performing
charter schools), and ignore the very low scores to which Detroit
charters are being compared, and ignore the negative effects of
virtual schools, and ignore the negative effects of the only statewide voucher programs that provide the best comparisons with DeVos's national agenda.
Also, see how Broome Street Academy
Charter High School used technology in the arts - including
virtual reality - to give their
students endless possibilities to create some extraordinary projects!
In spite of a wealth of information that points to K12, Inc. running a business operation that has poor returns by failing to adequately educate
students, yet continues to profit mightily from state taxpayers, some are still enthusiastic about the prospect of the
virtual charter school coming to North Carolina, including Rep. Larry Pittman, a supporter of
virtual charters.
In 2004, the Whitepine Board of Trustees saw the need and opportunity to open a statewide
virtual charter school to serve
students attending school from home.
The analysis of
charter management organizations is based on a «
virtual control record» method, in which
students in those schools are compared to «
virtual twins» who attend regular public schools the
charter students would otherwise have attended.
Q: Public school districts would be required to allow
students who are home schooled, attend an independent or
virtual charter school or attend private schools to participate in sports or extracurricular activities.
The team has developed an innovative method of comparing results for
charter students against their «
virtual twins» in district schools, and translating hard - to - understand standard deviation measures into a more easily digestible «additional days of learning.»
(Harrisburg, PA — May 5, 2011)-- Solanco School District in Quarryville is launching a program that gives district
students $ 1,000 to switch from their current PA cyber
charter school to the Solanco
Virtual Academy (SVA.)
Even though K12, Inc. is notorious for churning
students through its programs and failing to demonstrate academic progress, both of the companies»
virtual charter programs are likely to get the green light since the legislation compels the State Board of Education to get the pilot program up and running this fall.
«I think another part of the strategy is to distract from the growing body of evidence that things like
virtual charter schools do a terrible job in educating
students.
The misconception suggests that if the
charters,
virtual, and catholic schools are working to close the gap for
students than there is no need for the traditional schools.
[15]... things like
virtual charter schools do a terrible job in educating
students...: https://twitter.com/share?text=...things+like+
virtual+
charter+schools+do+a+terrible+job+in+educating+
students...&via=ncpolicywatch&related=ncpolicywatch&url=http://www.ncpolicywatch.com/2017/02/28/school-choice-advocates-push-rebrand-vouchers-
virtual-charters-legislators/
«This apparent lack of legal clarity is disconcerting and could be a factor limiting the participation of
students with disabilities in
virtual charter school programs.
Shreveport Times:
Virtual charter school enables
students to explore creativity http://bit.ly/1VRkDMo