The effects of aerosol injections are at least somewhat known, since
volcanic eruptions produce aerosols naturally and have produced cooling in the past.
Because of Io's low gravity, large
volcanic eruptions produce an umbrella of debris that rises high into space.
First,
volcanic eruptions produce major quantities of carbon dioxide (CO2), a gas known to contribute to the greenhouse effect.
One of the things I'm having trouble with is the uncertainties of aerosals and their effects on cooling, or the possibility of
volcanic eruptions producing particles that result in cooling.
Not exact matches
The extinction at the end of the Permian is thought to have been caused by
volcanic eruptions in Siberia over hundreds of thousands if not a million years that
produced what are known today as the Siberian Traps: lava fields covering much of northern Russia and originally encompassing nearly 3 million square miles with an average thickness of about 1,000 feet.
Some researchers have suggested that these gases might have been spewed out by the
volcanic eruptions that
produced the Siberian traps, a vast formation of
volcanic rock
produced by the most extensive
eruptions in Earth's geological record.
Does one major
volcanic eruption generate more climate - altering gas than that
produced by humans in their entire history?
Ultimately, he found that, while
volcanic eruptions would have spewed huge quantities of both sulfur dioxide and hydrogen sulfide into the atmosphere, it was the former that dissolved more easily in shallow waters,
producing large concentrations of sulfidic anions, in the form of sulfites and bisulfites.
Large reservoirs of magma stored deep in Earth's crust are key to
producing some of Earth's most powerful
volcanic eruptions, new research has shown.
«I had done some work modeling aerosols
produced by
volcanic eruptions for other projects, so I started looking into how we might detect an
eruption and what it would tell us.»
The research highlights the impact of
volcanic eruptions on climate, when particles
produced can reflect sunlight from Earth, causing long - lasting cooling.
Seismic waves are waves of energy
produced by earthquakes, explosions and
volcanic eruptions, which can travel long distances below Earth's surface.
In a study published online in the Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America, David Fee of the Alaska
Volcanic Observatory and Wilson Alaska Technical Center and his colleagues used these techniques to examine the ground - coupled airwaves
produced by recent
eruptions at Cleveland, Veniaminof and Pavlof volcanoes in Alaska.
Glass compositions of the YTT (open squares) are clearly distinct from tephra of the Rungwe
Volcanic Province (26) and of the Olkaria (27) and Eburru (28) volcanoes, Kenya, which have
produced rhyolitic
eruptions during the last 150 ka..
The most explosive
volcanic event of the Quaternary was the
eruption of Mt. Toba, Sumatra, 75,000 y ago, which
produced voluminous ash deposits found across much of the Indian Ocean, Indian Peninsula, and South China Sea.
Supervolcano isn't a true scientific term, Benson explained, but generally refers to a
volcanic eruption that
produces at least 1,000 cubic kilometers of material.
Ian Plimer in another contrarian tome included some even more made up facts: «massive
volcanic eruptions (e.g. Pinatubo) emit the equivalent of a years» human CO2 emissions in a few days» (p472) and «Volcanoes
produce more CO2 then the world's cars and industries combined» (p413).
Volcanic eruptions are episodic, and can
produce strong but temporary cooling.
Scientists at the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory and the Bonneville Power Administration think underground porous rocks
produced by
volcanic eruptions could be used as a large battery system.
The sulfate plot intrigued me, especially that huge spike roughly around 1300 A.D. I did some seeking and found some references to
volcanic eruptions that would have
produced such spikes.
So because the Earth was much warmer many millions of years ago and the Earth's climate has naturally changed due to asteroid impact,
volcanic eruptions, changes in the solar flux, the emergence of plants which
produced ~ 20 % oxygen content in the air and which in turn allowed animals to evolve, there's just no way that 7 billion humans can cause any problem at all.
And,
volcanic eruptions are very different from human
produced aerosols as they put the aerosol into the stratosphere, rather than the troposphere.
Robock, A., C. M. Ammann, L. Oman, D. Shindell, S. Levis, and G. Stenchikov 2009: Did the Toba
volcanic eruption of ~ 74k BP
produce widespread glaciation?
Immense flood basalts were accompanied by pyroclastic
eruptions and together
produced the Siberian Traps, an area of 2 million square kilometers of
volcanic rock, which formed suddenly, on the Earth's surface.
As I pointed out,
volcanic eruptions do not
produce cooling, especially on a regular thirty year schedule like their graph shows.
Humans, meanwhile, become more prone to disease if they are not exposed to enough sunlight to
produce vitamin D. «Our research shows that the climate anomaly, which covered all of the northern hemisphere, was the compound result of several
volcanic eruptions,» says Markku Oinonen, director of the Chronology Laboratory.
This caused an ever - increasing amount of energy to enter our system which
produced higher wind speeds, more violent earthquakes, and even more frequent
volcanic eruptions.
Though greenhouse gases are
produced naturally (e.g. a
volcanic eruption), the majority of the scientific community claims that human activity (e.g. burning fossil fuels) adds significant amounts of greenhouse gases to the atmosphere.
It may well be the case that only the systems that
produce forcings eg
volcanic eruption, solar winds, sunspot activity and the like could be non ergodic but still capable of yielding scenarios for climate modelling purposes.
Certainly an unusually calm solar cycle is playing a significant role in
producing all of this cold weather, but as you will see below the truth is that throughout human history
volcanic eruptions have
produced some of the coldest winters ever recorded.
Given the fact that internally the earth itself has large temperature changes which melts the upper mantle and deep crust
producing volcanic eruptions at the surface, it is not difficult to see that the thermal energy involved and the mass of the earth itself, that the earth's own internal temperature fluctuations might have bigger effect on the atmosphere's temperature than the sun.
Backing that up, NASA says that 1) sea surface temperature fluctuations (El Niño - La Niña) can cause global temperature deviation of about 0.2 °C; 2) solar maximums and minimums
produce variations of only 0.1 °C, warmer or cooler; 3) aerosols from natural sources such as
volcanic eruptions (Mount Pinatubo for example) have caused average cooling of 0.3 °C, but recent
eruptions have had not had significant effect.
While
volcanic eruptions surely warmed the ocean in the immediate vicinity of the
eruptions, the amount of heat they
produced compared to the large volume of the Arctic Ocean is small.
Forster et al. (2007) described four mechanisms by which
volcanic forcing influences climate: RF due to aerosol — radiation interaction; differential (vertical or horizontal) heating,
producing gradients and changes in circulation; interactions with other modes of circulation, such as El Niño - Southern Oscillation (ENSO); and ozone depletion with its effects on stratospheric heating, which depends on anthropogenic chlorine (stratospheric ozone would increase with a
volcanic eruption under low - chlorine conditions).
Also, note that aerosol droplets from
volcanic eruptions are much more dispersed than those from say aircraft exhaust plumes that do
produce a form of cirrus clouds under certain conditions.