In this sense,
the votes on devolution were republican - that the establishment of the Scottish Parliament and Welsh Assembly depended on the approval of electors made them «public things».
Not exact matches
Sandford rightly notes that — at present — asymmetric regional
devolution would therefore not lead to any restrictions
on MPs» ability to
vote on English - only matters in the House of Commons.
In essence, the Conservative approach to English
devolution focuses
on three themes: a better and more balanced economy; bespoke Growth Deals and decentralisation of powers to (large) cities which choose to have elected mayor; and English
Votes for English Laws (EVEL).
They have accepted that further
devolution to Scotland has been delinked from English
Votes on English Laws (although the Prime Minister does not seem to have read that bit).
It is much less than what George Cunningham insisted
on in the Scottish
devolution proposals that led to the 1979 legislation
on that; he insisted
on having 40 % for a yes
vote, whereas I am calling here for only 40 % of the electorate.
With both Labour and the Conservatives due to unveil proposals for more
devolution in the event of a No
vote in the referendum, the new material focuses
on attitudes towards the prospect of more
devolution.
The logic of your argument suggests it would be dishonest of the politicians not to include six
voting systems; a question offering all possible combinations of Lords reform; another
on whether to stay in or get out of Europe; another
on Scottish / Welsh independence /
devolution; whether to have a written constitution.
«I think with further
devolution to Scotland it becomes inconceivable to continue to allow Scottish members to
vote on everything that is happening in England when as you know English members and indeed Scottish members can't
vote on so much of what is happening in Scotland.
But Mr Cameron's decision to take
on «English
votes for English matters» threatens to derail Gordon Brown's «rapid» timetable for
devolution.
Asked about English
devolution 71 % of people thought that Scottish MPs should not be able to
vote on issues that affect only England (including the majority of Scottish respondents in the poll), 15 % of people thought they should.
Welsh Secretary David Jones will today exercise his right to sit and speak (though not
vote) in the Assembly for its debate
on the Queen's Speech, including changes to
devolution that involve giving income tax raising powers to the Welsh Government, subject to approval in a referendum.
During the Smith Commission negotiations
on further
devolution to Scotland, it was agreed to transfer legislative power from the UK parliament to Holyrood to allow 16 and 17 year olds to
vote in future Scottish Parliament elections.
Yet Labour's equivocal stance
on further
devolution to Scotland risks alienating its core
vote; and recent polls suggest that the Party is
on the verge of electoral meltdown in Scotland.
The party leadership wants to accompany enhanced
devolution for Scotland with a new rule that Scottish MPs can not
vote on matters that only affect people in England.
He said: «This is not an issue of who
votes on what in Westminster.This is about taking power away from Westminster - not
devolution to England or even
devolution to Scotland, it's
devolution in England,
devolution in Scotland.
The Scottish Parliament was created after a referendum
on devolution took place
on 11 September 1997 in which 74.3 % of those who
voted approved the idea.
The McKay Commission report into the consequences of
devolution on law - making found English resentment at Scottish and Northern Ireland MPs
voting on laws just for England was growing and that the status quo could not continue.
Critics of
devolution often cite the West Lothian question, which refers to the
voting power of non-English MPs
on matters affecting only England in the UK Parliament.
Having gained 47 per cent of the first round
vote (
on a turn - out of 26 per cent), Jarvis has a strong mandate to bring together the combined authority leaders and rubberstamp the city region's
devolution deal to enact the manifesto he campaigned
on, including making the case for a Yorkshire Mayor, which we would argue against making the first priority.
Alan Christie: now that the Smith report
on further
devolution of powers to Scottish Parliament is out, how is that likely to impact SNP
voting intention in Scotland?
MBRUNO Alan Christie: now that the Smith report
on further
devolution of powers to Scottish Parliament is out, how is that likely to impact SNP
voting intention in Scotland?
This could include: a referendum
on Europe; further
devolution of powers to cities, Scotland and Wales; the introduction of «English
Votes for English Laws»; and a new bill of rights to replace the Human Rights Act.
David Cameron's call for «English
votes on English laws» is simplistic and divisive, but Labour's alternative,
devolution to city and county regions, is not a panacea.
Brown, who was widely credited with playing a decisive role in helping the no side win last month's referendum, turned
on the Tories after they drew a link between further
devolution to Scotland and the creation of English
votes for English laws at Westminster.
Now, with Smith arriving
on the scene with a significant new
devolution agenda, Scottish politics may gradually revert from being dominated by the grievances of the 45 % who
voted yes to independence, to the quieter aspirations of the 75 % or more who tend to back increased powers for Holyrood.
Possible reasons include if Cameron resists the SNP's demands for greater
devolution of powers, if the UK
votes to leave the European Union or withdraw from the European convention
on human rights, or if the SNP wins a decisive victory at the Holyrood elections in 2016 having expressed a desire for another referendum in its manifesto.
Although the Times (and other Scottish news media) lead
on the poll's findings in respect of independence and
devolution (anti-independence, pro-devo-max which was also the most popular in a 3 - way choice), the poll's findings
on Westminster
voting intentions are rather more spectacular.
Although the Times (and other Scottish news media) lead
on the poll's findings in respect of independence and
devolution (anti-independence, pro-devo-max which was also the most popular in a 3 - way choice), the poll's findings
on Westminster
voting intentions are rather -LSB-...]