In Louisiana, private schools with fewer than 40 voucher students don't have to show basic competency among students in math, reading, social studies, and science.
«There's not ever been strong evidence that
voucher students do better than students of similar incomes who remain in the public schools,» Colvin told StateImpact in September.
The school's voucher students don't post great results on math and reading tests; last year, Our Lady earned the equivalent of a D - from the state.
The problem with vouchers in terms of student achievement is that there's not ever been strong evidence that
voucher students do better than students of similar incomes who remain in the public schools.
In many states, in fact,
voucher students do no better — and sometimes fare worse — than their peers in public schools.
In one study,
voucher students did no better than peers in the public schools for four years, then outpaced them in reading — but not math — in the fifth year.
com: Louisiana
voucher students did worse at new schools, study says http://bit.ly/1OsiQVO
Not exact matches
Voucher programs that affect only a fraction of
students do leave others behind, but that is not an argument against
vouchers; it is an argument in favor of a
voucher plan that is comprehensive.
Sharpton added that Devos — a longtime backer of charter and Christian schools --»
does not believe in public education,» and would transform federal school funding into a
voucher system that would favor a small percentage of well - off
students while neglecting the rest.
Ohio law requires that
voucher students are charged what they would otherwise pay if they didn't qualify for the financial help.
PDK (universal
vouchers, government funding emphasis):
Do you favor or oppose allowing
students and parents to choose a private school to attend at public expense?
Krueger further notes that «making
vouchers available
does not assure that
students switch to private schools.»
From James Coleman's early observational studies of high schools to the experimental
voucher evaluations of the past 15 years, researchers have routinely found that similar
students do at least as well and, at times, better academically in private schools than in public schools.
It
does not guarantee enrollment in a private school, but the $ 7,500
voucher should make such enrollments relatively common among the
students who won the scholarship lottery.
In every experimental evaluation of private school
voucher programs, the
students who won the
voucher lottery but
did not consistently use their
voucher to attend private schools have remained in the study over time as members of the treatment group, and the
students who lost the
voucher lottery but enrolled in private school have remained in the study as members of the control group.
[3] Would poor
students using
vouchers to attend private schools
do better than if they remained in their public systems?
What
do we know about the impact of school
vouchers on
student learning and longer - term outcomes?
These studies are rigorous precisely because they
do not simply compare
voucher students with «their peers in public school.»
Despite these differences, the bulk of the available, high - quality evidence on school
voucher programs suggests that they
do yield positive achievement effects for participating
students.
The report, «Special Choices:
Do voucher schools serve
students with disabilities?»
The treatment group included 1,358
students who received a
voucher offer; the control group included 1,279
students who
did not receive a
voucher offer.
In fact, there have been seven scientifically valid random - assignment analyses of
voucher programs, and all seven found either that all
voucher students perform significantly better than their nonvoucher contemporaries, or at least that most of them
do (in some studies the results for black
students, the majority of participants, are positive, while the results for other
students fail to achieve statistical significance).
Fifty percent of the parents of
voucher students said they were
doing «very well» as compared to 52 percent of public school parents.
Because the 18,500
voucher users
do not count in MPS revenue limits, $ 9,141 each was saved for the 90 percent of
voucher students we assume would have attended MPS, a total of $ 152.2 million.
Rep. Annette «Polly» Williams is backing a proposal by state education officials to bar private schools in the program from charging
voucher students registration and book fees that public schools
do not impose, according to Greg Doyle, the spokesman for the state education department, which proposed the rule last month.
In Chile,
students are found in four types of schools: elite schools that
do not accept
vouchers and charge considerably more than the
voucher; for - profit
voucher schools; nonprofit (usually religious)
voucher schools; and municipal schools.
So, twenty years after the enactment of Milwaukee's program, a growing body of research shows that
students receiving
vouchers do as well and often better than their peers in public schools and at a fraction of the taxpayer cost.
We
do know for a fact that parents and
students who are using the K — 12
voucher program in Washington, D.C., believe their private schools are much safer, and parents often list safety as a top reason for choosing a private school.
That said, Moe's analysis
does not, and can not, address the larger question of how social disparity would be distributed within each sector if all
students were given
vouchers to attend any school - public or private.
Still other researchers with national credentials report that low - income
voucher students in Milwaukee graduate from high schools at higher rates than
do public school
students.
By comparing only
students who entered the
voucher lottery, researchers controlled for differences between families that apply for
vouchers and those who don't.
Because the
voucher studies compare
students who won a
voucher to those who
did not — and those not receiving a
voucher very likely ended up in the new and improved public / charter system.
What Ravitch
does not understand is that this is an «intention to treat» analysis, in which all
students who started in private schools via the
voucher program are counted as if they had remained there, even if they transferred into public high schools.
And special education
vouchers even improve the quality of services for the disabled
students who remain in public schools because those schools risk losing
students to the
voucher program if they
do not serve the
students well.
In the three cities roughly half the
students initially took the
voucher that was offered to them (the takers), and about half
did not (the decliners).
On many topics — including school
vouchers, charter schools, digital learning,
student and school accountability, common core standards, and teacher recruitment and retention policies — the views of Hispanic adults
do not differ noticeably from those of either whites or African Americans.
A recent Wall Street Journal analysis of the Milwaukee
voucher program concludes that the share of
voucher students in a private school is the key to success — that private schools with few
students using
vouchers do well, while schools with many
students using
vouchers do poorly.
In 2009, Warren estimates, 82 percent of 9th grade
students in
voucher schools graduated from high school, while just 70 percent of 9th graders in the Milwaukee Public Schools
did.
In other words, the schools can
do what they like but if their
voucher - bearing
students don't learn enough to pass the state tests, the state will
do something about it — ultimately (under Louisiana regulations) eliminating those schools from eligibility to participate in the program.
A significant number of the
students who were offered
vouchers did not use them; similarly, a smaller proportion of those
students not offered a
voucher attended a private school anyway.
And the assessment shows that white
voucher students from more affluent families
do better — just as in public school.
It is reasonable to conclude that African - American
students» initial gains in the New York City school
voucher program were preserved but
did not increase between year one and year two.
The inadequate number of eligible applicants has led federal officials to drop plans for a study that would have compared the achievement of
voucher recipients with that of
students who requested the grants but didn't receive them.
Do students with
vouchers learn more in private schools or in those run by municipalities?
To estimate the impact of switching from a public to a private school, we
did not simply compare those
students who used a
voucher to enroll in a private school with all those who
did not.
They will note that almost half of the control group attended charter schools, so to a large degree this study is a comparison of how
students do in
vouchers relative to charters.
It is generally thought that targeted school
vouchers, i.e.,
vouchers limited to
students from low - income families, have more widespread support than
does a universal
voucher program, which would allow any family to make use of a government
voucher to attend a private school.
About one - third of Saint Martin's $ 6.6 million annual budget comes from the two
voucher programs, putting the school in a unique category among schools in Ohio with a high percentage of
voucher students: unlike other such schools, the state
does not pay the bulk of Saint Martin's bills.
Students using
vouchers to attend established private schools in Cleveland are slightly outperforming their public school counterparts in language skills and science, and
doing about the same in reading, math, and social studies, according to the latest independent evaluation of the program.
Second, Rick thinks there is an inconsistency in my suspicion that test - prep and manipulation are largely responsible for test score improvements by Milwaukee choice schools after they were required to take high - stakes tests, while I interpret research from Florida as showing schools made exceptional test score gains when faced with the prospect of having
vouchers offered to their
students if scores
did not improve.