Fifty percent of the parents of
voucher students said they were doing «very well» as compared to 52 percent of public school parents.
Not exact matches
Mark Otto
says that though he faces name recognition challenges, many of his
students are district residents, and they will
vouch for him as he makes his rounds.
David Prothero, associate superintendent of schools for the archdiocese,
says the 6,000 Catholic - school
voucher students represent nearly half of Milwaukee's Catholic school
students.
Ben Austin, director of the Los Angeles based organization leading the parent trigger movement, notes that his group, Parent Revolution, is pro-charter but «unambiguously» opposed to
vouchers, providing evidence,
says Butcher, that «
student - and parentcentric reforms» draw support from parents with diverse views on education reform.
In the case of private school choice, you're right that there's a mixed track record, though I would
say mostly positive if you look at the full body of evidence about what happens when you allow a
student to move from a public school to a private school using a
voucher.
This dire sequence started, he
says, with A Nation at Risk, the 1983 Reagan administration report that launched America on «experiments» such as «open classrooms, national goals, merit pay,
vouchers, charter schools, smaller classes, alternative certification for teachers,
student portfolios, and online learning, to name just a handful.»
«These descriptive data show how means tests and other provisions to target school
voucher programs to disadvantaged
students serve to minimize the threat of cream - skimming,» Wolf
says.
While
voucher opponents emphasized that the high court's refusal to review the case was not a ruling on the constitutionality of
vouchers for
students in religious schools, some supporters
said they were free to interpret the court's action as a «green light» to push for Milwaukee - style plans elsewhere.
«Carrying passports, birth certificates, luggage, and money
vouchers,
students proceed with their families to various stations set up around the building,» Goodman
said.
Officials in a San Antonio district
said last week they have lost nearly 600
students this fall to a new, privately financed
voucher program.
That
said, Moe's analysis does not, and can not, address the larger question of how social disparity would be distributed within each sector if all
students were given
vouchers to attend any school - public or private.
Almost 15 percent of
students in the United States are
said to have a disability under the procedures established by IDEA, so in states with special education
vouchers, the potential for program growth is considerable.
Bush has
said that he supports using
vouchers to allow
students from failing schools to attend private schools.
Confident that more of Washington's low - income public school
students will apply for the tuition
vouchers next year, federal officials
said a study would be launched at that time.
In some places, Catholic schools must participate in these, usually as a condition of receiving
students with
vouchers; in a handful of places, diocesan authorities have willingly joined in, but nobody would
say there's been a great rush by Catholic schools to be compared — with charter schools, with district schools, with other private schools, even with each other — on the basis of academic achievement.
Professor Warren's report, available here,
says that Milwaukee
students using
vouchers were 18 per cent more likely to graduate than MPS
students.
For the third time, a Florida court has struck down the state's best - known
voucher program, calling it unconstitutional because it allows
students to attend religious schools with taxpayer money — a violation, the court
said, of the state constitution.
«Private school
vouchers are not an effective way to improve
student achievement,»
said the White House in a statement on March 29.
It
says a large - scale
voucher study would help determine whether giving public school
students vouchers to pay for tuition at private schools can improve achievement, especially for
students in poor, urban areas.
«By mid-year, she was right up there with the rest of the
students,»
said Nelson - Paunescu, who receives a
voucher and is president of the Parent Teacher Fellowship.
«It's becoming more of a marketplace,»
said Pecchia, who two years ago raised tuition rates to $ 4,250 to match the value of the state's
vouchers for elementary
students and to $ 5,000 for high - school
students.
A
voucher student, he had attended Youngstown's Chaney High School as a freshman, but Tucker
said it was a «horrible experience.»
The former principal
said he supports the state's requirement that as a condition for receiving
vouchers, private schools must administer the state's proficiency tests to their
voucher students and report the results.
While opponents
said that
vouchers had no track record of improving
student performance, supporters countered that no alternative could be worse than Washington's public schools, which in any case were in line to receive more federal aid.
[7] These are not the same
students — a
student that uses a
voucher for,
say, two years, and then returns to a public school, is not in the sample of
students that used a
voucher for three or four years.
Let's
say you have 2,000
students choose a
voucher program.
«By allowing public funds to flow to private providers, Nevada's
voucher law abdicates this public responsibility to ensure quality education for every
student — and exposes families to greater educational risk,» Potter
said.
Among non-participating private schools, 28 percent
said that the inadequate scholarship amount played a role in their decision not to accept LSP
students, and 43 percent expressed concerns that the
voucher amount would not keep up with increasing costs.
But state - funded
voucher programs rarely catapult low - income
students into elite private schools with upper - income whites and Asians, education experts
say.
Secretary of Education William J. Bennett last week unveiled his proposal for distributing Chapter 1 aid through
vouchers,
saying it would benefit disadvantaged
students by «enabling parents to choose the educational program that best meets the needs of their children.»
The authors
say that the existing research on
student achievement, while still preliminary, bodes well for
vouchers.
In her Senate confirmation hearing, DeVos did not
say that she would seek to add a mandatory school choice
voucher - like program into the Every
Student Succeeds Act, but did tell senators,» I would hope I could convince you of the merits of that, maybe in some future legislation, but certainly not in a mandate from the department.»
First, he uses a 2002 GAO study to
say that
students who receive
vouchers fare no better than comparable public school
students, even though a veritable mountain of evidence to the contrary has been published since then.
To support this, they
say: «An independent evaluation by Patrick Wolf of the University of Arkansas found no improvement for
students participating in the Milwaukee or Washington, D.C.,
voucher programs.»
See what research
says about the relationship between
vouchers and
student achievement... Americans want consistent standards for
students.
The op - ed also cites a recently released study of first year data from the U.S. Department of Education's Institute for Education Sciences
saying it «adds to a growing body of education research that concludes
vouchers may harm rather help
student achievement.»
PA Educuation Secretary Ronald Tomalis
says that he supports standardized testing for
voucher students.
In May of 2017 in her testimony before the House Appropriations Subcommittee on Labor, Health and Human Services, Education, and Related Agencies, Betsy DeVos declined to
say whether she would protect
students against discriminatory policies in private schools that receive federal funding through
vouchers.3
She asked DeVos for her view on maintaining legal protections for
voucher students, and DeVos began her answer by
saying she was glad that Hassan had been able to «find the right opportunity» for her son.
Fast forward to 2017: President Donald Trump and U.S. Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos have championed a plan to provide federal funding for private school
voucher systems nationwide, which would funnel millions of taxpayer dollars out of public schools and into unaccountable private schools — a school reform policy that they
say would provide better options for low - income
students trapped in failing schools.
In a recent investigation of the program, NPR found some private schools turning away children with disabilities and LGBTQ
students, but it was impossible to
say, at the time, whether those
students who are using
vouchers are any better off academically.
Advocates for the proposal, including GOP Sen. Alberta Darling of River Hills, have
said not providing
students with disabilities the same opportunity to receive school
vouchers as other
students is unfair.
Two schools that together took in 141 of the program's 1,716
students last year are no longer part of the
voucher program, Cork
said at the hearing.
Education Week: Parents of
Students With Disabilities Seek
Vouchers Despite Risks, Report
Says http://bit.ly/1UEzgRm
«The
voucher floodgates are wide open as unaccountable private schools take tens of millions of dollars from
students in neighborhood public schools,»
said WEAC President Betsy Kippers.
Supporters
say private schools offer an option for parents whose children have been failed by traditional public schools, but opponents note schools receiving public
vouchers maintain policies that are openly discriminatory toward LGBTQ
students and their families.
Facing pressure from critics who
said that
vouchers would not go to the neediest
students with that high of an income limitation, lawmakers dropped it to level that confers eligibility for the federal free and reduced price lunch program.
«Otto Banks...
said this
vouchers proposal is more politically feasible than a previous measure which would have eventually allowed
vouchers for any
student of a low - to middle - income family, regardless of whether the
student were within the attendance boundary of a failing school.»
Using unflinching language, Ms. Feldman — who
said she would remain president of the New York City teachers» union while heading the national union — spoke at a news conference about the importance of creating high standards and denounced using
vouchers that channel
students and dollars from public schools to private schools.
Report after report proves that public schools provide more opportunities and
students there perform better than those in
voucher schools,»
said WEAC president Betsy Kippers in a statement.