An assessment of the primary sources of spread of global
warming estimates from coupled atmosphere — ocean models.
In fact, there is an accumulating body of reviewed, published research shaving away the high end of the range of possible
warming estimates from doubled carbon dioxide levels.
None of
the warming estimates from thawing permafrost are in the latest reports by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.
Using instead the 4.0 + / -0.8 C
warming estimate from the Annan and Hargreaves (2013; doi: 10.5194 / cp -9-367-2013) global reconstruction of temperature changes at the LGM implies an even lower ECS best estimate, of 1.56 C.
Not exact matches
Using these data, researchers fine - tuned
estimates from previous foram studies that captured polar conditions to show tropical oceans
warmed substantially in the Eocene, but not as much as polar oceans.
They found glacial fjords hundreds of meters deeper than previously
estimated; the full extent of the marine - based portions of the glaciers; deep troughs enabling Atlantic Ocean water to reach the glacier fronts and melt them
from below; and few shallow sills that limit contact with this
warmer water.
Now a new analysis is
estimating the pace of species movement because of both climate change and land use, revealing new pressures that stem
from local decisions to build, plant and cut on the
warming landscape.
By reconstructing past global
warming and the carbon cycle on Earth 56 million years ago, researchers
from the Niels Bohr Institute among others have used computer modelling to
estimate the potential perspective for future global
warming, which could be even
warmer than previously thought.
The calculations are in line with
estimates from most climate models, proving that these models do a good job of
estimating past climatic conditions and, very likely, future conditions in an era of climate change and global
warming.
In one study published in Geophysical Research Letters in 2007, scientists at the Max Planck Institute for Meteorology in Hamburg, Germany,
estimated the mass redistribution resulting
from ocean
warming would shorten the day by 120 microseconds, or nearly one tenth of a millisecond, over the next two centuries.
In the case of Scottsbluff, Vatistas and his team found that the temperature inside the tornado would have dropped
from a comfortably
warm background temperature of 27o C to a chilly 12o C. And at the tornado's centre, the researchers
estimated the air density would have been 20 per cent lower than what's found at high altitudes.
Indeed, atmospheric chemists have
estimated that the combined
warming effect of these trace gases will soon equal or exceed the effect
from carbon dioxide.
The material on Amazon forest dieback was in the IPCC assessment as were the numbers on recent sea level (thought the IPCC did not use the information on recent contributions
from land ice in their
estimate for 21st century
warming.)
This translates into more CO2 in the atmosphere and therefore more
warming, with
estimates ranging
from 0.62 w / m2 to 1.09 w / m2.
Data
from BOREAS allows researchers to
estimate how much carbon dioxide trees pull out of the atmosphere and store within their structures, a value used in some models to predict the role of forests in a future,
warmer world.
7It is particularly ironic that Lomborg would offer such a ridiculously precise
estimate of the cost of the impacts of climate change
from carbon dioxide emissions, inasmuch as the entire thrust of his books chapter on «global
warming» is that practically nothing about the effects of greenhouse gases is known with certainty.
Complementary analyses of the surface mass balance of Greenland (Tedesco et al, 2011) also show that 2010 was a record year for melt area extent... Extrapolating these melt rates forward to 2050, «the cumulative loss could raise sea level by 15 cm by 2050 ″ for a total of 32 cm (adding in 8 cm
from glacial ice caps and 9 cm
from thermal expansion)- a number very close to the best
estimate of Vermeer & Rahmstorf (2009), derived by linking the observed rate of sea level rise to the observed
warming.
But the change
from 2004 to 2007 in the sun's output of visible light, and the attendant
warming at Earth's surface of 0.1 watt per square meter, is roughly equivalent to the overall forcing of the sun on the climate over the past 25 years —
estimated by the U.N. Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change to be an additional 0.12 watt per square meter.
Heatwaves
from Europe to China are likely to be more intense and result in maximum temperatures that are 3 °C to 5 °C
warmer than previously
estimated by the middle of the century — all because of the way plants on the ground respond to carbon dioxide in the atmosphere.
Co-author Dr Eleanor Burke,
from the Met Office Hadley Centre, said: «The advantage of our approach is that permafrost loss can be
estimated for any policy - relevant global
warming scenario.
As shown later in this paper, the global
warming potential of the annual emissions of CH4
from Amazonian wetlands is equivalent to about 30â $ «40 % of the
estimated annual accumulation of C in woody biomass of mature Amazonian forests.»
Indeed, the main quandary faced by climate scientists is how to
estimate climate sensitivity
from the Little Ice Age or Medieval
Warm Period, at all, given the relative small forcings over the past 1000 years, and the substantial uncertainties in both the forcings and the temperature changes.
The kinder, gentler model
from the Hadley Centre for Climate Prediction and Research in the United Kingdom
estimated a wetter,
warmer future: Rainfall may increase 20 percent to 25 percent, mean annual temperatures could increase 2 degrees Fahrenheit by 2030 and 4 degrees by 2100.
The IPCC's overall
estimate of global sea level rise, which includes all the other factors that affect sea levels, such as melt
from Greenland's ice sheets and the oceans expanding as they
warm, is 60 cm by 2100 (with a likely range of 42 to 80 cm).
In the end, Archibald concludes that the
warming from the next 40 ppm of CO2 rise (never mind the rest of it) will only be 0.04 degrees C. Archibald's low - ball
estimate of climate change comes not
from the modtran model my server ran for him, but
from his own low - ball value of the climate sensitivity.
This is much less than the current «best
estimate» of about 3 deg.C, and would imply that there is * not * any unfelt
warming «still in the pipeline»
from greenhouse gases we've already emitted.
We assess the heat content change
from both of the long time series (0 to 700 m layer and the 1961 to 2003 period) to be 8.11 ± 0.74 × 1022 J, corresponding to an average
warming of 0.1 °C or 0.14 ± 0.04 W m — 2, and conclude that the available heat content
estimates from 1961 to 2003 show a significant increasing trend in ocean heat content.
Estimates from the study indicate that the freezing line could lift by as much as 3,900 feet by 2100, which could expose the majority of glaciers in the region to temperatures above 32 °F in
warm - weather months.
(e)
Estimated temperature response to anthropogenic forcing, consisting of a
warming component
from greenhouse gases, and a cooling component
from most aerosols.
[Further Response: Our
estimates of the magnitude of future global
warming do not come
from ice core data, and do not depend on it in any way.
The Copenhagen Diagnosis authors used IPCC Fourth Assessment Report (AR4) projections as well as post-AR4 analysis to
estimate that emissions reductions of around 40 %
from industrial nations are needed to make it likely to keep global
warming below 2 °C.
Using Mg / Ca paleothermometry
from the planktonic foraminifera Globigerinoides ruber
from the past 500 k.y. at Ocean Drilling Program (ODP) Site 871 in the western Pacific
warm pool, we
estimate the tropical Pacific climate sensitivity parameter (λ) to be 0.94 — 1.06 °C (W m − 2) − 1, higher than that predicted by model simulations of the Last Glacial Maximum or by models of doubled greenhouse gas concentration forcing.
A doubling of CO2
from 300 ppm in 1880 to 600 ppm in 2100 has a best
estimate of 1.8 degrees (scenario B1) or about 2.3 degrees
warming since 1880, which happens to be precisely the sensitivity figure given by Schmittner et al..
Another way to
estimate climate sensitivity
from both models AND observations is to calculate the ratio of observed
warming to forecast
warming... then multiply that by the ECS value used in the model.
Every year, approximately two - thirds of North Pacific humpback whales,
estimates range
from 4,000 to 10,000 whales, migrate to Hawaii's
warm waters.
Every year, approximately two - thirds of North Pacific humpback whales (
estimates range
from 4,000 to 10,000 whales) migrate to Hawaii's
warm waters to mate, and to bear and nurse their calves.
Every year, approximately two - thirds of North Pacific humpback whales,
estimates range
from 4,000 to 10,000 whales, migrate to Hawaii's
warm waters to mate, and to bear and nurse their calves.
Adolph Gottlieb's Burst # 3
from 1967 (Lot 536) should be sold for $ 1,400,000 — $ 1,800,000, Alexander Calder's Untitled (Demi Cône)
from 1972 (Lot 513) for $ 1,250,000 — $ 1,800,000, while Kenneth Noland's A
Warm Sound In A Gray Field
from 1961 (Lot 505) and Joan Mitchell's Magnolia
from 1978 (Lot 553) are both
estimated at $ 1,200,000 — $ 1,800,000.
But rather since carbon dioxide, for example, is generally accepted as one of the leading causes of Global
Warming we should be able to come up with a somewhat accurate
estimate of where all the carbon dioxide comes
from.
To prime the pump, I mentioned a couple of instances that I reported on Dot Earth, including a report
estimating 300,000 deaths a year
from global
warming and contentious statements made about the predicted die - back of the Amazon rain forest at a climate - science summit in Copenhagen early last year.
According to Sir Nicholas, «Scientists have been refining their assessment of the probable degree of
warming for a given level of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere», and «ranges
from 2004
estimates are substantially above those
from 2001 — science is telling us that the
warming effect is greater than we had previously thought.»
Presumably the water vapour feedback in models is dealt with by determining /
estimating / calculating the radiative forcing
from water vapour and then making some assumption about the water vapour response to atmospheric
warming (e.g. assuming constant relative humidity).
What I'm trying to get at is some simplistic
estimate of the water vapour feedback that results
from an enhanced CO2 - induced
warming of say 1.1 oC
from the CO2 RF of around 4 Wm - 2.
The standard usage attributes physical meaning to the feedbacks which may be incompatible with the one implied here i.e. a sum of unspecified fudge terms to be added (or subtracted
from) the
estimated warming.
Item 8 could be confusing in having so many messages: «It is extremely likely that more than half of the observed increase in global average surface temperature
from 1951 to 2010 was caused by the anthropogenic increase in greenhouse gas... The best
estimate of the human - induced contribution to
warming is similar to the observed
warming over this period....
In particular, the sensitivity of the Laurentide ice sheet to
warming (which you can
estimate from paleo) is not likely to be the same as for Greenland.
These results suggest that sea surface temperature pattern - induced low cloud anomalies could have contributed to the period of reduced
warming between 1998 and 2013, and offer a physical explanation of why climate sensitivities
estimated from recently observed trends are probably biased low 4.
Has anyone else done analysis similar to Giving What You Can where they try to
estimate the benefit say in price per tonne of CO2 equivalent
from various global
warming charities?
Using Mg / Ca paleothermometry
from the planktonic foraminifera Globigerinoides ruber
from the past 500 k.y. at Ocean Drilling Program (ODP) Site 871 in the western Pacific
warm pool, we
estimate the tropical Pacific climate sensitivity parameter (λ) to be 0.94 — 1.06 °C (W m − 2) − 1, higher than that predicted by model simulations of the Last Glacial Maximum or by models of doubled greenhouse gas concentration forcing.
Using carbon dioxide emissions data
from 2006 and 1750 - for an
estimate of preindustrial levels - Jacobson found that each extra degree of
warming accounted for roughly 1,000 out of every 50,000 - 100,000 air pollution - related deaths.