Recent updates:
Added 1/14: First Showing (additional critic), Slashfilm (additional critic)
Added 1/8: Birth.Movies.Death (additional critics), Parallax View, The Tracking Board
Added 1/7: Film Journey, The Film Stage (additional critic), First Showing (additional critic)
Added 1/5: The Film Stage (additional critics), In Review, Moving Picture Blog, The Playlist (additional critics), Slashfilm (additional critics), Taste of Cinema
Added 1/3: CBS News, Den of Geek [UK], Film Pulse, The Film Stage (substituted individual lists for consensus list), Hidden Remote, The Playlist (additional critics), PopCulture.com, Reverse Shot, ScreenAnarchy, Slant (substituted individual lists for consensus list), Slashfilm, Wichita Eagle
Added 12/31: artsBHAM, Cape Cod Times, CinemaBlend (additional critics), Collider (additional critics), Criterion [The Daily], Criterion Cast, The Film Stage, First Showing, Flavorwire, The Globe and Mail, The Hollywood Reporter / Heat Vision, Lincoln Journal Star, Monkeys Fighting Robots, NOW Magazine, Omaha World - Herald, Paste, People, ReelViews, Salt Lake City Weekly, San Antonio Current, Screen Daily, SF Weekly, These Violent Delights, Toledo Blade, Uncut, Under the Radar, Vancouver Observer, Vancouver Sun
Added 12/29: The Arts
Desk, Austin American - Statesman, Austin Chronicle, Awards Daily, Boston Globe, Boston Herald, CinemaBlend (additional critics), Cleveland Scene, Collider (additional critics), The Daily Beast, Deadline, Film Journal International, Houston Chronicle, Ioncinema, Las Vegas Review - Journal, New Orleans Times - Picayune, New York Post, Paper, The Playlist, San Diego City Beat, San Francisco Chronicle, San Francisco Examiner, St. Louis Post-Dispatch, Salt Lake Tribune, Seattle Weekly, Shepherd Express, The Stranger, Tallahassee Democrat, Toronto Star, Tucson Weekly, Tulsa World, Uproxx, The Virginian - Pilot, Washington City Paper,
White City Cinema
Added 12/27: Awards Campaign, Baltimore Beat, Buffalo News, Chicago Daily Herald, CinemaBlend, Collider, Film School Rejects, GameSpot, JoBlo, Metro UK, Newsweek, Observer, San Jose Mercury News, Seattle Times, Sydney Morning Herald, Tampa Bay Times, Thrillist, USA Today, Village Voice (Wolfe), Wired UK
Added 12/22: Chicago Sun - Times, Den of Geek [US], The Guardian, Mashable, Metro US, Sioux City Journal, Star Tribune, The Verge, Wired
Added 12/21: BBC, Chicago Reader, The Commercial Appeal, IGN, Las Vegas Weekly, TimeOut New York, Village Voice
Added 12/20: A.V. Club, Crave, Esquire, The Independent, Spectrum Culture
Added 12/19: The Atlantic, Birth.Movies.Death., CineVue, Newsday, NPR, WhatCulture
Added 12/18: Arizona Republic, Yahoo!
Added 12/17: Dazed, Flood Magazine, New Zealand Herald, Salon, ScreenCrush, The Star - Ledger (NJ.com), Time Out London, Total Film
Added 12/15: BuzzFeed, Christian Science Monitor, Detroit News, Los Angeles Times, Philadelphia Daily News, Vox
Added 12/14: Associated Press, Chicago Tribune, Consequence of Sound, Little
White Lies, Los Angeles Daily News, RogerEbert.com, TheWrap
Added 12/13: Evening Standard, Variety
Added 12/12: The Hollywood Reporter, Huffington Post, PopCrush
Added 12/11: CBC, The Observer [UK], Wall Street Journal
Added 12/8: The New Yorker, Rolling Stone, Slant
Added 12/7: Culture Trip, IMDb, The Ringer, Slate, Time, Us Weekly
Added 12/6: Cahiers du Cinéma, New York Times, Vogue, Vulture (Yoshida), Washington Post
Added 12/5: Scorecard launched with 15 lists.