Average annual retail electricity sales in the nine participating states from 2009 through 2012 were 6 % below the annual sales in 2005. (eia.gov)
In part due to the impacts of increased energy efficiency and distributed solar, 2017 had the lowest observed annual electricity sales of any year since 1998. (synapse-energy.com)
Of these states, 10 also have some form of retail choice for electricity sales. (communitysolaraccess.org)