"Honest critique" means providing feedback or expressing an opinion about something in a truthful and sincere way, without being overly critical or attempting to hide any negative aspects. Full definition
People want the dirt and hear the harsh criticisms and honest critiques of the games industry. (randomtower.com)
A critique group isn't worth anything if you don't give honest critiques, with suggested solutions, to help writers improve their craft. (madgeniusclub.com)
I did appreciate the calls for patience and the fact that he gave some seemingly honest critiques on some of these players. (sbnation.com)