Garmin contended that specific combinations of prior art references created a reasonable likelihood that the challenged claims were invalid. (brookskushman.com)
While Judge Voss did not elaborate on the infringement finding and on the reasons for which his court ordered a stay, I remember from the trial that the key prior art reference cited by Apple was a version of the UMTS specifications that predated the filing of Samsung's patent application. (fosspatents.com)
Each petition alleged that claims in a Canon patent were unpatentable in light of the same prior art reference. (brookskushman.com)