This critique of reasonableness review on law is not the only one available, but it is the one underwriting deference skepticism in the U.S. today. (doubleaspect.blog)
But, in the sentencing universe after Booker, and especially when the circuit judges on the panel are split, having district judges as swing voters on reasonableness review just does not seem quite right. (sentencing.typepad.com)
Without further qualifications, this strong Chevron approach would look much like the presumption of reasonableness review in Edmonton East. (doubleaspect.blog)