In a large church, no - one gets to see the pastor... average size, some people do... again, same gang over and over. (nakedpastor.com)
Same gang of stalker trolls on both sites. (goodereader.com)
Along the way you'll also bump into characters from the first game like Bonny McFarlane and, most interestingly, John Marston, who at that point would be in the very same gang you had to hunt down in Red Dead Redemption. (wolfsgamingblog.com)