In a significantly powerful review paper (Ghil et al 2011) the arguments as posed in a binary way, are not as simple as he thinks nor ameanable to archaic methodology that has been to justify a number of spurious arguments eg Lenton. (judithcurry.com)
In my comments I referred to «The depravity of their cynicism...» regarding opponents raising spurious arguments in opposition to Golden Rice. (irri.org)
«As with any issue, there may be a small, vocal group who raises spurious arguments that have nothing to do with this application,» she added. (goodereader.com)