Hugely openhearted and packed with terrific moments that are both spiky and resonant, this undemanding... (contactmusic.net)
Martin Starr gets some absolutely terrific moments of physical comedy here, like when he mimes grabbing Cindy's ass, but the top one is him sitting in the chair and trying to make it sound like a fart. (tv.avclub.com)
Sure, one can nitpick here and there at the things that don't quite work, but with so many terrific moments, those are easily looked over for the overall sense of fun and romanticism. (qwipster.net)