I made this three tiered wood slice stand as part of another project that needs it's own blog post, but I was happy with how well it suited the rustic romantic theme of the shower with the raw wood edges and pretty glass pieces inside. (personallyandrea.com)
Our favorite gifts include the baby's first photoshoot outfit matching the theme of the nursery (jungle)(which was also the theme of the shower). (babycenter.com)
A stuffed animal, like a teddy bear, is always a great standby, but you could also opt for something that coordinates with the theme of the shower or the baby's nursery. (verywellfamily.com)