It would depart, obviously, from Cobb's contention that «listeners,» responding in the mode of presentational immediacy, are alone «capable of useful criticism or indeed of any serious discussion of musical composition» (John B. Cobb, Jr., «Toward Clarity in Aesthetics, Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, 18 [1957], p. 178). (religion-online.org)
Second, it's not about praise, pats on the head, and trophies for participation, nor is it about shielding trainees from useful criticism. (sciencemag.org)
Lively and full of errata, if not too much useful criticism or context beyond «this scared me when I was a kid» (see above for my identical contribution to this conversation), it's the preferred option over the first commentary reuniting stars Robinson and Gene Barry, who do better than you'd expect (especially Robinson, who's evidently boned up for this project) but still just provide the usual behind - the - scenes stories. (filmfreakcentral.net)