The phrase "witch finger" refers to a spooky or eerie-looking finger, resembling that of a witch, often associated with Halloween or witches from fairytales or movies. Full definition
If you want to make witch finger cookies, just add a bit of green food coloring to the dough. (listotic.com)
You'll find witch fingers, monsters, skeletons, spiders and all the scary cookie ideas that you can imagine. (essentialketo.com)
Headless Gingerbread Men from Noshing with the Nolands Swirly Halloween Cookies from Hezzi - D's Books and Cooks Enchanted Pumpkin Cookies from NinjaBaking The Witch's Cauldron Cookies from Cookie Dough & Oven Mitt Witch Finger Cookies from Karen's Kitchen Stories Pumpkin Macarons from A Baker's House French Butter Cookie (Bones) from Made with Love Pumpkin Cookie Bars from Food Lust People Love Spooky Almond Cookies from Basic N Delicious (sweetcinnamonhoney.com)