For example, just last term, the U.S. Supreme Court held that a defendant's constitutional right to
effective assistance of counsel under the Sixth Amendment is so sacrosanct that violation of the right is grounds for overturning a conviction, even in the absence of showing of actual prejudice.
She has served as an expert witness on the death penalty and
on effective assistance of counsel, testified before the Louisiana legislature and frequently given expert commentary for news media.
As part of what may be a multi-year, sea change in the law of lawyering, the SCOTUS issued two more opinions that extended the constitutional guarantee
of effective assistance of counsel to the plea bargaining stage of criminal matters.
The crux of the issue was whether Mr. Shofman's lawyer failed to allow Mr. Shofman to make the decision on whether to testify at his own trial and whether that failure, if it did occur, created a situation
where effective assistance of counsel was lacking.
According to this press release summarizing the report, misdemeanor prosecutions are costing taxpayers and compromising defendants» Sixth Amendment right to
effective assistance of counsel:
The majority rejected Padilla's argument, explaining that the lawyer's advice on immigration status was collateral to the criminal defense component of his representation, to which the Sixth Amendment right to
effective assistance of counsel is attached.
coerced confessions, [Footnote 16] by the use of perjured testimony known by the prosecution to be such, [Footnote 17] or without
the effective assistance of counsel, [Footnote 18] have also been held to be exertions of state authority in conflict with the fundamental rights protected by the Fourteenth Amendment.
I understand that the detainees» plight raises significant constitutional questions, but so too do the dozens of cases involving indigent criminals arrested on false warrants or deprived of
effective assistance of counsel or forced to confess.
Justice Campbell found that Mr. Shofman was denied
the effective assistance of counsel at his trial.13 Further, His Honour found that the ineffective assistance of counsel prejudiced Mr. Shoffman because had the decision on whether to testify been left to him, he would have elected to testify.14
Mr. Shofman appealed his conviction, arguing that he was denied
the effective assistance of counsel at trial.
Rates like these compromise indigent defendants» constitutional rights to
effective assistance of counsel and a fair trial, argue a group of court - appointed lawyers in Philadelphia, who've filed suit for a pay increase in federal court, according to this report.
We come at last to Sullivan's claim that he was denied
the effective assistance of counsel guaranteed by the Sixth Amendment because his lawyers had a conflict of interest.