At common law, administrative actors owe a
duty of procedural fairness to individuals whose rights or interests are affected by specific, individualized decisions.
The issue here was whether delay was a
matter of procedural fairness; or alternatively, whether the respondent's denial of a stay was an exercise of a discretionary power.
In the urgency of the situation, I conclude that it did and that there was no failure
of procedural fairness on that account.
The application judge's decision to dispose of the application on a basis that was not advanced by the parties amounts to a
denial of procedural fairness.
The first step to implementing changes in court operations or procedures is a good understanding
of procedural fairness as applied to the courts.
Additionally, low
levels of procedural fairness have been linked with self - reported health problems and higher levels of psychiatric disorders among employees.
This is justified on
grounds of procedural fairness — a lawyer unable to reveal information relating to the retainer would be unable to defend themselves against such action.
In applying procedural fairness in their courts, court administrators should consider several
aspects of procedural fairness that arguably are not sufficiently appreciated.
With respect to the
issue of procedural fairness, the court found that the applicants were awarded the procedural fairness to which they were entitled.
British Columbia's controversial Tobacco Damages and Health Care Costs Recovery Act («the Act») is back in the courts.1 This time around the dispute isn't on the Acts constitutionality, but instead pits the right to privacy in medical data against a persons or corporation's right to a «fair playing field» in litigation, or the
principle of procedural fairness grounded in the Rule of Law.
[70] For the reasons already provided, I conclude that the Minister's decision to make the Report's allegations regarding Ms. Blais public, before ensuring that Ms. Blais was given reasonable notice of the allegations and an opportunity to give evidence in response, was unreasonable and in breach of the duty
of procedural fairness owed to Ms. Blais.
The Court confirmed that the applicant «was entitled to a relatively high
standard of procedural fairness given the issues at stake,» but rejected each of the applicant's arguments.
Having done so, it was, in my opinion, a breach
of procedural fairness for the Arbitrator to refuse to consider [its] argument on the basis that the other two parties did not want it considered.
The Parole Board, [2013] UKSC 61 has already provoked interesting commentary on the relationship between the common
law of procedural fairness and the European Convention on Human Rights.
The question of deference on
questions of procedural fairness will continue to hang over Canadian administrative law until it is argued and authoritatively resolved by the Supreme Court.
In
terms of procedural fairness, the conduct of the Tribunal «must be sufficiently serious to offend our most basic notions of morality and justice» and judicial intervention is only warranted when «the Tribunal's conduct is so serious that it can not be condoned under the law of the enforcing State» (para 65).
Adhering to basic
concepts of procedural fairness during divorce, child custody proceedings and other family law matters, helps to ensure that those entering the courtroom come away from the process feeling they were treated fairly by the judicial system.
This is a decision that the CCD is finds consistent with the
notion of procedural fairness required from a statutory administrative decision maker.
The decisions in Brar and in Abetew make it very clear that in Manitoba, at least, where an individual's livelihood is at stake on the basis of a tribunal's licensing decision, the principles
of procedural fairness require that written reasons be provided.
To the extent that the costs incurred in providing an oral hearing is a consideration of relevance in determining the
content of procedural fairness, those costs in the present area of government decision - making could well be considerable (para. 15).
The video excerpt to the left is from the National Center for State Courts «Writing Opinions and Orders in Controversial Cases,» explains the importance
of procedural fairness when writing opinions and orders in controversial cases.
My post welcoming Evans J.A.'s recent suggestion that weight could be accorded to administrative
determinations of procedural fairness questions has provoked some debate, some in the comments section of that post, some on Twitter and some in emails to me.
18 Nevertheless, because most of the appeal decisions on the standard in summary judgment have involved concerns of a lack
of procedural fairness rather than a lack of efficiency, this asymmetry could have a conservative influence on the overall approach recommended by the Court of Appeal.
In fact, it may amount to a breach
of procedural fairness if an adjudicator refuses a party's request to make an opening statement.
More importantly, the written reasons and greater transparency demonstrated here should help avoid
many of the procedural fairness issues raised in Pridgen.
The Court of Appeal also dismissed arguments made on behalf of XH that the exercise of such power was, in any event, unlawful on the basis of EU law
norms of procedural fairness.
In any event, the relevance of support for the use of these exceptional procedures to introduce even a degree
of procedural fairness where none had existed before to the debate on this Bill is limited.