One group found on average charters have a slight edge
over traditional public schools in reading and about the same in math but acknowledged charter quality is uneven across the states and across schools.
With little new education policy expected in the remainder of NYC Mayor Bill de Blasio's first term — and a quiet session on education concluding in Albany — the
debate over traditional public schools versus charter schools has shifted to a new battleground: school safety.
Yes, charter schools have an advantage
over traditional public schools because, among other things, they don't have to take students midyear — and because families who choose to apply to charters are more likely to be motivated and engaged.
For example, many of the foundations in our sample favored the funding of national over local advocacy organizations, charter
schools over traditional public schools, and alternative certification programs over colleges of education.
We can't say for sure that charters would retain their productivity advantage
over traditional public schools if they were funded on par with district - run schools, but it sure would be interesting to see what happens under something close to funding equity.
The debate of charters
over traditional public schools appears to be most heated in Rutherford County, a rural manufacturing community in the Blue Ridge Mountains foothills with unemployment rates nearly twice the state average.
As CapitalNewYork reported, Gov. Christie responded to the Mayor, «thousands of your constituents are choosing [charter schools] every
year over traditional public schools in Newark because they give their children a better chance at a brighter future.»
«I think it raises a red flag for the district as they move toward
turning over traditional public schools into charter schools,» said Marytza Gawlik, who taught at Detroit's Wayne State University until this summer.
With little new education policy expected in the remainder of Mayor Bill de Blasio's first term — and a quiet session on education concluding in Albany — the
debate over traditional public schools versus charter schools has shifted to a new battleground: school safety.
You know, NYSUT has focused — as have parents — their attention on the governor in lots of different ways, including the fact that there's been lots of criticism about... preferring charter
schools over traditional public schools.
Assertions that the sector has «fulfilled one of its core missions — equity for students — by establishing itself as a primarily urban phenomenon with significant chains of schools that are closing achievement gaps» (Lake, 2013, p. 1) are countered by claims that «charter schools, on average, don't have an academic advantage
over traditional public schools, but they do have a significant risk of leading to increased segregation» (Rotberg, 2014, para 2).